Here's a random list of stuff that annoys, confuses, or otherwise bothers me.
1. The smell of peanut butter
Status: Bother
I really cannot stand the smell of peanut butter.
By this I mean I literally get nauseated when I get a whiff of the stuff.
I blame this diet I went on in 8th grade. One of the strange meals involved 2 tablespoons of natural (meaning unsweetened) peanut butter on a bread.
It was an unholy alliance, and I still don't make peanut butter cookies.
2. My blood is a second class citizen.
Status: Annoying/confusing/bother
Whenever I heard anyone talk about giving blood, there was always the mention of how the most requested blood type in hospitals is O type blood.
I always feel a little flicker of shame.
See, my blood type is A-positive, because I am apparently just that awesome. Back in 1986 or so, there were at least a couple of people who decided to donate blood who were A-positive. Yet somehow...it doesn't have that O-type magic that everyone just craves.
You always get a feeling that the nurses are all like "oh...A-positive...well, I guess we'll take it" in their minds. Then you feel a little defiant.
Yeah, heck right, my blood's good enough. What.
3. I'm female, so I'm all over chocolate like Dracula in a blood bank.
Status: Confusing
I'll take a second to explain. While I was in college, I heard this one a lot. "Girls, don't you just crave chocolate sometime..." "Oooh, truffles..." "Girls, doesn't chocolate just make everything better..."
Uhm. No.
Now, I do like chocolate. I imagine a lot of people do, and I've only met a couple of people who don't prefer it. Fine by me; my candy of choice is Haribo Happy Colas, because they are scientifically proven to be that ambrosia stuff the Greeks kept going on about.
But, in an interesting twist of things, my fiance is the one with the sweet tooth. Mostly, sugar makes my teeth hurt and gives me a touch of heartburn. I don't eat meal replacement bars for that reason.
I actually refer to my taste as a "meat tooth."
I also don't drink, so I had a double advantage at BJU while all my fellow women students had their wits compromised by the presence of Lindor truffles.
4. "I pushed my blond hair away from my face, and my violet eyes stared across the land..."
Status: Annoyance, to say the very least.
I see this a lot in way too many first-person books. Usually they have younger characters. Sometimes they're self-published, sometimes they're bestsellers.
There's a pretty big reason you probably should avoid this.
By probably, I mean definitely.
Ready for it?
Here goes...
No one describes themselves when they're telling a story. I don't care if you're writing in a journal or telling a story to someone face-to-face. If you've resorted to having your main character describe himself or herself, then back off for a second. Look at it through the eyes of another person.
And don't freaking do it.
Honestly, readers will picture a character any way they please, regardless of your input. Also, if that character absolutely has to take the time to describe how mind-blowing their eye color is, then they're at best self-absorbed.
And yes, I just snuck writing tips in. Deal with it.
5. "Are you German?/You look German..."/"You look like your name should be Helga."
Status: Bother/Back the heck away now.
The first two aren't so bad, except they don't make a whole lot of sense.
I went to Bob Jones University for college, and because of apparent nutritional deficiencies within fundamentalism, I was among the taller of the students there. Also, people from Michigan are short. So there's that.
Apparently being tall makes you German, in BJU-World.
Now, sure, it would make sense if I had actual blond hair and fit any stereotype whatsoever, but I have brown hair. Yes, I have blue eyes, but that particular trait is more indicitive of my actual ancestry, which is partly of the British Isles. And BJU people are really good at asking awkward questions, like if you're German because "you're so tall."
The Helga thing actually hurt a little. I'm not even sure where it came from, or what the intent was, but it was said with a derisive giggle, by people I didn't even know well. It bothered me because nothing about my clothes or hairstyle invited such a statement. In BJU-World, someone with the name "Helga," however inaccurate the perception, is heavy-browed and lumbering.
I already know I'm quite far from being pretty by anyone's standards, but this little incident was just one more reason I was glad to graduate and get away from there, mostly because people there were willing to say anything about you behind your back, as long as it's "good clean fun."
6. I have a history degree, so I just know tons about the Civil War.
Status: Confusing
'Cause I really don't.
I mean, I really, really don't.
I never took a single Civil War-focus class in all my four years of college. Heck, I only took one American history class beyond the required U.S. History classes. Most of my choices included the ancient world and the 20th century. My personal favorite choices were a study of Germany from 1933 to 1945 and World War II. I woulda taken a bazillion classes on the latter if I could.
My favorite century is the 20th. I like seeing how it all meshes together. I love seeing how everything, from technology to pop culture to warfare, changed in just 100 years. The 20th century is like no other.
'Bout the only thing I know about the Civil War is the correct pronunciation of Antietam. Call me negligent, but it wasn't what really captured my attention as I grew up. At some point in high school, WWII caught my eye and everything just unfolded from there.
7. "Well, you can do stuff giving blood, because you're taller/bigger/like a giant..."
Status: Really freaking annoying
I think I first noticed this in earnest a little while back, when I was
discussing a blood drive with some people. Now, as I've said before, I'm
not exactly petite. By that I mean that I am 5 feet, 9 inches tall.
Not exactly a giant, either.
See, when I was a baby, my white blood cells decided to go on a witch
hunt. Like most witch hunts, it went badly, and my poor innocent red
blood cells were being eaten in pretty great numbers. I imagine it
looked somewhat like when the T-rex in Jurassic Park ate that goat. I had
to receive a blood transfusion of packed red cells. That's a heck of a
lot of A-positive blood types. The crisis was averted, and I am here
today, delivering your daily-ish dose of snark.
So you could say that giving blood is close to my heart.* I've done it
two times now in my lifetime, and I'm trying to get my fiance to do it
so we can have an excuse to go out for a steak afterwards. I try to
encourage people to give blood if they can, when the subject comes up.
The replies are always what really get me. I can see if someone just
plain doesn't want to. I mean, if you're squeamish, that's fine. Or,
alternatively, you can't, for whatever health reason.
The annoying part is when smaller people say stuff like "well, I'd just
get sick and have to go to bed all day; you're a lot bigger than me, so
you can afford to give blood."
Uhm, actually, no I can't. The average human has about 10 pints of
blood. The range for women tends to be 8-10 pints. I have as much blood
in my body as I'm supposed to; when I give a pint, it's a lot.
See, I have trouble gauging what "a lot of food" is. What seems to me
like it might be a lot of food very likely isn't. The last time I gave
blood, I'd had a good breakfast, but "eat a lot" for me, that day, meant
adding a piece of toast, which, you might have guessed, isn't iron
rich. Couple that with having an upset stomach sometime that morning. I
was running on empty and decided to give anyway. For some reason,
filling the bag didn't take as long the second time around. I'd estimate
5-10 minutes, which is short for a donation. I got pretty nauseous
after that. If I actually bled a pint, it would make a mess.
So no, tiny people, actually, I can't just "afford" to do without a
whole pint of my blood. It's not money. I can't save it up and decide to
splurge on a trip to the Red Cross. So spare me the excuses and just be
honest, okay?
So now you know.
And it probably explains a lot.
*I swear, that wording was an accident.
Showing posts with label generalizations. Show all posts
Showing posts with label generalizations. Show all posts
Thursday, February 2, 2012
That Really Bugs Me
Labels:
20th century,
blood,
bob jones university,
Eastern North Carolina,
excuses,
experiences,
generalizations,
history,
world war ii,
WWII history,
zombies
Wednesday, October 20, 2010
How to Annoy Your Audience: Stereotypes and Generalizations
The typical fictional New York City will usually be characterized by a few things. First, fictional NYC citizens are rude and soulless. Old people and children will always be roughly shoved out of the way of tough city folk, and money and success define a fictional NYC citizen's life. Second, in the fictional NYC, soulful, green-haired, spontaneous, and poor artists populate Greenwich Village or any of the nicest neighborhoods in Manhattan. Third, you have to use a specific lingo in order to receive food from any eating establishment. Topping it all off, the negative vibes in fictional NYC are enough to cause a river of Pepto pink slime to run under the city and bring back the soul of Dracula's rival-in-meanness neighbor.
Uh-huh.
See how annoying all that is? Not only that, it's pretty insulting to make all those generalizations. (Except for the last part. Ghostbusters, you get an exemption.) New York City, to the average tourist, is quite fast-paced, but the people are awesome and the city is amazing. Okay, my second point was first made in my creative writing textbook, but it is true. People tend to put poverty stricken, fictional artists in a lovely loft apartment in Greenwich Village. Only thing is, Greenwich is a beautiful neighborhood and it's pretty expensive to live there. (Also, I don't know too many artists, but I do know that most of them are fun people who are focused on their work rather than doing random and typical free-spirited things.) Also, since most New Yorkers speak English, they understand perfectly when you say "I'd like a cheeseburger and an iced tea, please."
Now we can move on to the stereotypical South.
In the stereotypical South, everyone everywhere drawls everything. Sentences take five minutes to finish. Cotton is still king, and football is the life of everyone who's anyone. Southern belles always have an air of treachery about them, and every upstanding woman wears pearls. There is also lots of background music, usually consisting of a harmonica or some slow, methodical picking of random guitar strings. The stereotypical South, Louisiana especially, also tends to be a choice residential area for vampires. They like the football programs, I suppose.
While music and vampires aren't necessarily stereotypes, everything else is. How do I know this? Well, I live in the South. Fiction that includes Southern locations and a Gone with the Wind accent permeating all the speech is, quite frankly, annoying. (No, I didn't intend that Rhett Butler allusion there. That's just a bonus.)
Granted, I do live in North Carolina. Cotton wasn't king here so much as tobacco. Being more of a vaguely British/pirate persuasion, we don't speak all that slowly. True, there are certain people who insist on the haughty, Southern blue-blood, old money thing, but even that has a different flavor than somewhere like, say...Georgia. There aren't old plantation houses on every block. (In truth, only about 4% of the antebellum Southern population actually lived on a plantation.) Recently, I've read somewhere that North Carolinians speak more of a "proper English" than other states, stemming from the many English settlers in the state. North Carolina is pretty unique, actually.
It's not the only unique place though. When a character is described as having a "Southern" accent, and when that accent is the only defining feature of that character, the writer is cheating both herself and the readers. For one thing, every state has a different accent, or two different, or three. (North Carolina has at least three regional differences in accents, spanning from the Coastal Plains, which I have, and the Western North Carolina accent.) "Southern" characters who are Southern in accent only are annoying, flat, and less than they could be.
British accents can be the same way. There are many different accents in the British isles, and saying that someone has a "slight British" accent (as Abra Ebner does in Feather) is a little bit lazy. Not only is it lazy, it also means that you're cheating yourself out of some character development and dialogue, and this goes for any accent. Instead of your main character observing that another character has a British/Southern/whatever accent, have them make conversation. It might look something like this: "The boy had an accent, but Susie couldn't place it. 'Where are you from?' Louis looked up from his book. 'I'm from....'" This conversation establishes characterization. If your main character doesn't want to be embarrassed by asking such a question, imply that and let them find out later.
If you're unsure about a location, and you want to write about it, please do your research. My complaint with many books is that the author simply does not do research in key areas. If you set your stories in a real life location, but get things blatantly wrong (you'll see more of this in my analysis of Feather) about the area, then someone is bound to notice. (Spoiler alert: Feather mentions the "hillsides of London" once...but London is a metropolitan area. Ravines of New York? Crashing waves in Oklahoma? I've never been to London, but Doctor Who is sometimes set there and 28 Days Later was a great story partly set in London...I have a good idea of what it looks like.) When you don't bother to get details right because you assume that no one will know or care, you insult your readers.
Also, there's generalizations about people that you never want to make. Many times, I am assumed to be Goth, and I am not. I do wear a lot of darker colors, for various reasons. Mostly taste. I do like dark red lipstick (classy!) and lace. (I even wear pearls, but I swear I stay away from the hoop skirts.) Also, I tend to be seen as a pessimist. (I'm not.) While I realize that I probably invite these generalizations (unintentionally...), they're not fair in writing. Again, defining a character solely by appearance, dress, or accent is a bad idea. You end up with flat characters who cannot grow or change because they have no substance to change from. The same applies to places. Defining New York City, the South, Southern California, or anywhere based on what you've read in books or seen in movies is going to prove problematic. That's why it's important to write what you know. If you want to do differently, then at least research what and where you are writing about. Your story will make more sense and will seem more real.
Check back for my next post. Right now, I'm reading through Guardian, the sequel to Feather. I hope to have a review of that up soon, and an analysis of Feather that can help you see where a story can go wrong. I'll also be writing about characters next. Stay tuned, and thanks for stopping by.
Uh-huh.
See how annoying all that is? Not only that, it's pretty insulting to make all those generalizations. (Except for the last part. Ghostbusters, you get an exemption.) New York City, to the average tourist, is quite fast-paced, but the people are awesome and the city is amazing. Okay, my second point was first made in my creative writing textbook, but it is true. People tend to put poverty stricken, fictional artists in a lovely loft apartment in Greenwich Village. Only thing is, Greenwich is a beautiful neighborhood and it's pretty expensive to live there. (Also, I don't know too many artists, but I do know that most of them are fun people who are focused on their work rather than doing random and typical free-spirited things.) Also, since most New Yorkers speak English, they understand perfectly when you say "I'd like a cheeseburger and an iced tea, please."
Now we can move on to the stereotypical South.
In the stereotypical South, everyone everywhere drawls everything. Sentences take five minutes to finish. Cotton is still king, and football is the life of everyone who's anyone. Southern belles always have an air of treachery about them, and every upstanding woman wears pearls. There is also lots of background music, usually consisting of a harmonica or some slow, methodical picking of random guitar strings. The stereotypical South, Louisiana especially, also tends to be a choice residential area for vampires. They like the football programs, I suppose.
While music and vampires aren't necessarily stereotypes, everything else is. How do I know this? Well, I live in the South. Fiction that includes Southern locations and a Gone with the Wind accent permeating all the speech is, quite frankly, annoying. (No, I didn't intend that Rhett Butler allusion there. That's just a bonus.)
Granted, I do live in North Carolina. Cotton wasn't king here so much as tobacco. Being more of a vaguely British/pirate persuasion, we don't speak all that slowly. True, there are certain people who insist on the haughty, Southern blue-blood, old money thing, but even that has a different flavor than somewhere like, say...Georgia. There aren't old plantation houses on every block. (In truth, only about 4% of the antebellum Southern population actually lived on a plantation.) Recently, I've read somewhere that North Carolinians speak more of a "proper English" than other states, stemming from the many English settlers in the state. North Carolina is pretty unique, actually.
It's not the only unique place though. When a character is described as having a "Southern" accent, and when that accent is the only defining feature of that character, the writer is cheating both herself and the readers. For one thing, every state has a different accent, or two different, or three. (North Carolina has at least three regional differences in accents, spanning from the Coastal Plains, which I have, and the Western North Carolina accent.) "Southern" characters who are Southern in accent only are annoying, flat, and less than they could be.
British accents can be the same way. There are many different accents in the British isles, and saying that someone has a "slight British" accent (as Abra Ebner does in Feather) is a little bit lazy. Not only is it lazy, it also means that you're cheating yourself out of some character development and dialogue, and this goes for any accent. Instead of your main character observing that another character has a British/Southern/whatever accent, have them make conversation. It might look something like this: "The boy had an accent, but Susie couldn't place it. 'Where are you from?' Louis looked up from his book. 'I'm from....'" This conversation establishes characterization. If your main character doesn't want to be embarrassed by asking such a question, imply that and let them find out later.
If you're unsure about a location, and you want to write about it, please do your research. My complaint with many books is that the author simply does not do research in key areas. If you set your stories in a real life location, but get things blatantly wrong (you'll see more of this in my analysis of Feather) about the area, then someone is bound to notice. (Spoiler alert: Feather mentions the "hillsides of London" once...but London is a metropolitan area. Ravines of New York? Crashing waves in Oklahoma? I've never been to London, but Doctor Who is sometimes set there and 28 Days Later was a great story partly set in London...I have a good idea of what it looks like.) When you don't bother to get details right because you assume that no one will know or care, you insult your readers.
Also, there's generalizations about people that you never want to make. Many times, I am assumed to be Goth, and I am not. I do wear a lot of darker colors, for various reasons. Mostly taste. I do like dark red lipstick (classy!) and lace. (I even wear pearls, but I swear I stay away from the hoop skirts.) Also, I tend to be seen as a pessimist. (I'm not.) While I realize that I probably invite these generalizations (unintentionally...), they're not fair in writing. Again, defining a character solely by appearance, dress, or accent is a bad idea. You end up with flat characters who cannot grow or change because they have no substance to change from. The same applies to places. Defining New York City, the South, Southern California, or anywhere based on what you've read in books or seen in movies is going to prove problematic. That's why it's important to write what you know. If you want to do differently, then at least research what and where you are writing about. Your story will make more sense and will seem more real.
Check back for my next post. Right now, I'm reading through Guardian, the sequel to Feather. I hope to have a review of that up soon, and an analysis of Feather that can help you see where a story can go wrong. I'll also be writing about characters next. Stay tuned, and thanks for stopping by.
Labels:
accents,
characters,
dialogue,
generalizations,
nyc,
regional,
stereotypes,
the South
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)